How do you comfort grieving an eight-year-old when you don’t believe in God?
Our family recently had to put down Pepsi, a cat who had been with us for about ten years. She was part of our family before any of our children were born. In fact, we’d had her for a month or two longer than we’d even been married, so the decision to end her life after a long battle with kidney failure was incredibly difficult.
Our family recently had to put down Pepsi, a cat who had been with us for about ten years. She was part of our family before any of our children were born. In fact, we’d had her for a month or two longer than we’d even been married, so the decision to end her life after a long battle with kidney failure was incredibly difficult.
My daughter was having an especially hard time, and I found myself wondering how to explain death to her in a way that would comfort her without telling her something I didn’t believe.
I decided to be honest. But I wasn’t going to turn my daughter’s grief into an argument about religion, either.
I told my daughter that one of the reasons we were so sad was that Pepsi had meant so much to us. She wasn’t just an animal who lived in our house. She was part of the family, woven into our everyday lives.
When someone has been around for that long, you get used to their presence. You expect them to be there. Then one day they aren’t, and it feels almost as though part of your own life is missing.
That was how I tried to explain it to her. There was a hole in the air where Pepsi used to be. All the ordinary moments she had occupied were suddenly empty.
I didn’t try to make that sadness go away. I wanted her to understand that we were hurting because we had loved Pepsi, and that there was nothing wrong with feeling that loss.
Pediatrician Dipesh Navsaria, writing for the American Academy of Pediatrics, advises parents to acknowledge children’s grief instead of trying to hurry them out of it. He also recommends small memorials and allowing children to ask questions at their own pace.[1] I found that reassuring. The small piece of fur I saved didn’t solve anything, but it gave our loss something tangible to hold on to.
There was another part of the sadness that was harder to explain. We knew Pepsi had died, but what, if anything, happened to her once she was gone?
I told my daughter that people have very different answers to those questions. I explained that some people, including me, believe that when we die, our conscious experience ends. We don’t go somewhere else. We’re simply gone.
Then I told her about other beliefs. I explained the Christian idea of heaven, where people believe life continues after death in a place of peace and happiness. She liked that one.
I also explained reincarnation, the idea that a person can be born into another life after dying. And I described the belief that some part of us might return to, or become one with, the universe.
I wasn’t presenting all of these possibilities as equally supported by evidence. I wanted her to know what people believe and why someone might find those beliefs comforting. I also wanted her to know where I stood.
I don’t have evidence that Pepsi went to heaven, became another animal, or continued existing as a spirit. So I couldn’t promise my daughter that any of those things had happened. But I assured her that I HOPED there was some sort of afterlife.
And I do hope. I hope that there might be something after death, even though I don’t believe we have good evidence of it. I don’t think there’s anything inconsistent about admitting both of those feelings.
There is a difference between being honest with a child and overwhelming them with every fear or unanswered question an adult has. I wasn’t trying to give my daughter a lecture on consciousness, biology, or theology. I was trying to help her understand what had happened to her cat.
Childhood bereavement specialist David J. Schonfeld explains that children need to understand that death is permanent, that the body stops functioning, that living things eventually die, and that death has physical causes. He also warns that phrases such as “gone to sleep” can confuse young children or even make sleep frightening.[2]
That’s especially relevant when a pet has been euthanized. We may use gentler language because we’re uncomfortable, but children still need to understand that the animal has died and isn’t going to wake up.
At the same time, a child doesn’t have to absorb every part of that reality in a single conversation. Some days they want an explanation. Other days they want to cry, look at pictures, ask another question, or just do something ordinary. We can answer what they ask and leave room for the next conversation.
I also read The Hare-Shaped Hole (affilaite link) with my daughter. All credit of course goes to my wonderful wife that had heard of the book in pursuit of her Master's in Social Work. Written by John Dougherty and illustrated by Thomas Docherty, The Hare-Shaped Hole gave us a wonderful exploration of grief.[3]

The story follows Bertle, a turtle, after he loses his best friend, Hertle the hare. Bertle searches for Hertle, becomes angry, pleads for him to return, and struggles with the space his friend has left behind. The book describes that absence with a line that Immediatly resonated with me and that was repeat countless times as we comforted her:
It’s such a simple way to describe grief. Someone was there. You loved having them there. Now the space they occupied feels painfully empty.
In the story, a kindly bear named Gerda helps Bertle remember the things he loved about Hertle. As those memories return, the dark hole begins to change. The book doesn’t need to settle what happens after death to say something useful about what happens to those of us who are left behind.[3]
That’s why I wanted to read it with my daughter. It was something we could share while facing a loss neither of us could undo. The book gives a child a way to picture grief without requiring a religious answer. It doesn’t make the missing friend come back, and it doesn’t ask us to pretend the loss was small. It makes room for sadness, love, and memory to exist together.
Hope is not the same as certainty
I understand why a parent might want to say, “Pepsi is in a better place.” It’s an easy sentence to reach for when your child is crying and you desperately want to make things better.
For a parent who genuinely believes in heaven, that statement may be an honest expression of faith. But for me, it would have been a promise I couldn’t support. I didn’t want to teach my daughter that comforting answers become facts simply because we need them to be true.
I also didn’t want her to think she had to choose between grieving Pepsi and hoping that somehow they might meet again. There’s nothing wrong with wishing for something beyond death. The problem comes when we blur the distinction between what we wish, what we believe, and what we know.
The Child Mind Institute recommends direct, age-appropriate explanations, giving children ways to express grief, and helping them preserve memories through stories, photographs, or other activities. Its guidance also recognizes that families may draw comfort from different beliefs about an afterlife.[5]
I think that leaves room for an atheist parent to be both skeptical and tender. We can say that we don’t know of an afterlife without treating hope as foolish. We can acknowledge uncertainty without suggesting every possibility has the same evidence behind it
I decided to be honest. But I wasn’t going to turn my daughter’s grief into an argument about religion, either.
The space left behind
I told my daughter that one of the reasons we were so sad was that Pepsi had meant so much to us. She wasn’t just an animal who lived in our house. She was part of the family, woven into our everyday lives.
When someone has been around for that long, you get used to their presence. You expect them to be there. Then one day they aren’t, and it feels almost as though part of your own life is missing.
That was how I tried to explain it to her. There was a hole in the air where Pepsi used to be. All the ordinary moments she had occupied were suddenly empty.
I didn’t try to make that sadness go away. I wanted her to understand that we were hurting because we had loved Pepsi, and that there was nothing wrong with feeling that loss.
Pediatrician Dipesh Navsaria, writing for the American Academy of Pediatrics, advises parents to acknowledge children’s grief instead of trying to hurry them out of it. He also recommends small memorials and allowing children to ask questions at their own pace.[1] I found that reassuring. The small piece of fur I saved didn’t solve anything, but it gave our loss something tangible to hold on to.
What I told her about the afterlife
There was another part of the sadness that was harder to explain. We knew Pepsi had died, but what, if anything, happened to her once she was gone?
I told my daughter that people have very different answers to those questions. I explained that some people, including me, believe that when we die, our conscious experience ends. We don’t go somewhere else. We’re simply gone.
Then I told her about other beliefs. I explained the Christian idea of heaven, where people believe life continues after death in a place of peace and happiness. She liked that one.
I also explained reincarnation, the idea that a person can be born into another life after dying. And I described the belief that some part of us might return to, or become one with, the universe.
I wasn’t presenting all of these possibilities as equally supported by evidence. I wanted her to know what people believe and why someone might find those beliefs comforting. I also wanted her to know where I stood.
I don’t have evidence that Pepsi went to heaven, became another animal, or continued existing as a spirit. So I couldn’t promise my daughter that any of those things had happened. But I assured her that I HOPED there was some sort of afterlife.
And I do hope. I hope that there might be something after death, even though I don’t believe we have good evidence of it. I don’t think there’s anything inconsistent about admitting both of those feelings.
Children deserve answers they can understand
There is a difference between being honest with a child and overwhelming them with every fear or unanswered question an adult has. I wasn’t trying to give my daughter a lecture on consciousness, biology, or theology. I was trying to help her understand what had happened to her cat.
Childhood bereavement specialist David J. Schonfeld explains that children need to understand that death is permanent, that the body stops functioning, that living things eventually die, and that death has physical causes. He also warns that phrases such as “gone to sleep” can confuse young children or even make sleep frightening.[2]
That’s especially relevant when a pet has been euthanized. We may use gentler language because we’re uncomfortable, but children still need to understand that the animal has died and isn’t going to wake up.
At the same time, a child doesn’t have to absorb every part of that reality in a single conversation. Some days they want an explanation. Other days they want to cry, look at pictures, ask another question, or just do something ordinary. We can answer what they ask and leave room for the next conversation.
The hare-shaped hole
I also read The Hare-Shaped Hole (affilaite link) with my daughter. All credit of course goes to my wonderful wife that had heard of the book in pursuit of her Master's in Social Work. Written by John Dougherty and illustrated by Thomas Docherty, The Hare-Shaped Hole gave us a wonderful exploration of grief.[3]

The story follows Bertle, a turtle, after he loses his best friend, Hertle the hare. Bertle searches for Hertle, becomes angry, pleads for him to return, and struggles with the space his friend has left behind. The book describes that absence with a line that Immediatly resonated with me and that was repeat countless times as we comforted her:
a hole in the air where a hare ought to be.[4]
It’s such a simple way to describe grief. Someone was there. You loved having them there. Now the space they occupied feels painfully empty.
In the story, a kindly bear named Gerda helps Bertle remember the things he loved about Hertle. As those memories return, the dark hole begins to change. The book doesn’t need to settle what happens after death to say something useful about what happens to those of us who are left behind.[3]
That’s why I wanted to read it with my daughter. It was something we could share while facing a loss neither of us could undo. The book gives a child a way to picture grief without requiring a religious answer. It doesn’t make the missing friend come back, and it doesn’t ask us to pretend the loss was small. It makes room for sadness, love, and memory to exist together.
Hope is not the same as certainty
I understand why a parent might want to say, “Pepsi is in a better place.” It’s an easy sentence to reach for when your child is crying and you desperately want to make things better.
For a parent who genuinely believes in heaven, that statement may be an honest expression of faith. But for me, it would have been a promise I couldn’t support. I didn’t want to teach my daughter that comforting answers become facts simply because we need them to be true.
I also didn’t want her to think she had to choose between grieving Pepsi and hoping that somehow they might meet again. There’s nothing wrong with wishing for something beyond death. The problem comes when we blur the distinction between what we wish, what we believe, and what we know.
The Child Mind Institute recommends direct, age-appropriate explanations, giving children ways to express grief, and helping them preserve memories through stories, photographs, or other activities. Its guidance also recognizes that families may draw comfort from different beliefs about an afterlife.[5]
I think that leaves room for an atheist parent to be both skeptical and tender. We can say that we don’t know of an afterlife without treating hope as foolish. We can acknowledge uncertainty without suggesting every possibility has the same evidence behind it
.
I can’t tell my daughter where Pepsi went after she died. But I can tell her that Pepsi was here. She lived with us for roughly a decade. She was part of our family, and we loved her.
I can tell her that the sadness she feels isn’t something to be ashamed of. She doesn’t need to stop missing Pepsi because an adult is uncomfortable watching her grieve. We can talk about her, keep the little reminders, and remember the years we got to spend with her.
None of that brings Pepsi back. Memories don’t erase the loss, and a picture book can’t make death less permanent. But love doesn’t suddenly become meaningless because the life it was attached to has ended.
When I think about the conversation I had with my daughter, I don’t think I needed to give her a perfect explanation of death. I needed to tell her the truth as best I understood it, listen to her, and let her know that she wasn’t alone in being sad.
Maybe there is something beyond this life. I hope there is. But I don’t need to claim that Pepsi is waiting for us somewhere to say that her life mattered.
.
Sources
[1] Navsaria, Dipesh. “When a Pet Dies: How to Help Your Child Cope.” HealthyChildren.org, American Academy of Pediatrics.
[2] Schonfeld, David J. “Helping Young Children Grieve and Understand Death.” Young Children 74, no. 2 (May 2019). National Association for the Education of Young Children.
[3] Dougherty, John. The Hare-Shaped Hole. Illustrated by Thomas Docherty. Frances Lincoln Children’s Books, 2024. (affiliate link)
[4] Kirkus Reviews. “The Hare-Shaped Hole.” Review, October 7, 2023.
[5] Ehmke, Rachel. “Helping Children Deal With Grief.” Child Mind Institute. Updated June 26, 2026.
What I can promise my daughter
I can’t tell my daughter where Pepsi went after she died. But I can tell her that Pepsi was here. She lived with us for roughly a decade. She was part of our family, and we loved her.
I can tell her that the sadness she feels isn’t something to be ashamed of. She doesn’t need to stop missing Pepsi because an adult is uncomfortable watching her grieve. We can talk about her, keep the little reminders, and remember the years we got to spend with her.
None of that brings Pepsi back. Memories don’t erase the loss, and a picture book can’t make death less permanent. But love doesn’t suddenly become meaningless because the life it was attached to has ended.
When I think about the conversation I had with my daughter, I don’t think I needed to give her a perfect explanation of death. I needed to tell her the truth as best I understood it, listen to her, and let her know that she wasn’t alone in being sad.
Maybe there is something beyond this life. I hope there is. But I don’t need to claim that Pepsi is waiting for us somewhere to say that her life mattered.
.
Sources
[1] Navsaria, Dipesh. “When a Pet Dies: How to Help Your Child Cope.” HealthyChildren.org, American Academy of Pediatrics.
[2] Schonfeld, David J. “Helping Young Children Grieve and Understand Death.” Young Children 74, no. 2 (May 2019). National Association for the Education of Young Children.
[3] Dougherty, John. The Hare-Shaped Hole. Illustrated by Thomas Docherty. Frances Lincoln Children’s Books, 2024. (affiliate link)
[4] Kirkus Reviews. “The Hare-Shaped Hole.” Review, October 7, 2023.
[5] Ehmke, Rachel. “Helping Children Deal With Grief.” Child Mind Institute. Updated June 26, 2026.
Comments
Post a Comment