Religion has shaped our laws, our communities, our ideas about right and wrong, and even the way we mourn the dead. For many people, it offers friendship, hope, and a reason to get out of bed in the morning.
But how much of that actually requires religion? We can love our families without believing in God. We can build hospitals, oppose injustice, and investigate the universe without appealing to scripture. And we can find purpose in a life that may be the only one we have.
Imagine a world where people gradually stopped believing in gods, not because a government forbade religion, but because supernatural explanations no longer persuaded them. Would it be a kinder, freer, more knowledgeable world? Or would we discover that religious institutions had been providing things we weren't prepared to replace?
A completely nonreligious world has never existed, so we can't know its future. But philosophy, social science, and the experience of relatively secular societies give us something better than a guess: evidence about which parts of human life depend on religion, and which do not.
Who decides what is right without God?
One common objection to atheism is that without divine commandments, morality becomes a matter of personal preference. If no one is watching from heaven, why shouldn't someone lie, steal, or hurt others whenever doing so is convenient?
That question assumes religion solves the problem of moral justification. Yet philosophers were questioning the relationship between goodness and divine approval more than two thousand years ago. In Plato's Euthyphro, Socrates asks:
Put simply, is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is already good? The first answer raises the worry that morality depends on whatever God happens to command. The second leaves us asking what makes an action good apart from the command.
Christian philosophers have offered serious responses, including the view that goodness reflects God's nature rather than arbitrary decisions. That may answer the charge of arbitrariness within their theology, but it does not establish that we must believe in God to recognize cruelty or reason about justice.
John Stuart Mill offered one influential nonreligious approach in his 1863 essay Utilitarianism:
Mill's proposal can be criticized, particularly when the interests of a majority threaten the rights of a minority. But it puts a public question on the table: who is helped or harmed by an action, and why should we accept that harm? Other secular approaches emphasize duties, rights, fairness, or character. They disagree, just as religious moral systems do.
Our moral instincts also have a social history. Cooperation, empathy, and concern for reputation can be studied as features of human behavior, even if those facts alone cannot tell us what we ought to do. Explaining how morality develops is not the same as proving a moral rule.
The claim that belief in God is necessary for morality is already losing public support. In Pew Research Center's 2025 survey, published in March 2026, 68 percent of American adults said belief in God was not necessary to be moral and have good values. In Sweden, 89 percent said the same.[3]
A world without religion wouldn't stop us arguing about justice. It would require us to defend moral rules without expecting the words 'God says so' to end the discussion.
What changes when scripture no longer sets the limits?
Consider a classroom where students are learning how life evolved. Some religious people accept evolution, and many scientists have been believers. The conflict arises when a religious account is presented as a competing scientific explanation without meeting scientific standards.
In Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science, the National Academy of Sciences explained that science tests explanations against evidence and that creation science does not satisfy those methods. It argued that evolution, rather than a religious account of creation, belongs in the science curriculum.[4]
A society doesn't need to abandon religious belief to teach science properly. It needs to reject the idea that a doctrine deserves scientific status simply because people consider it sacred. In a world without religion, that particular conflict would largely disappear.
The same principle extends to law. Religious citizens should be free to practice their beliefs, argue for their values, and participate in politics. But a law that restricts someone else's freedom should have reasons that citizens outside that religion can examine.
A marriage law, a medical policy, or a school curriculum should be defensible in terms of rights, evidence, and consequences. Saying that God disapproves might explain a believer's conviction, but it doesn't give everyone else a reason to surrender their freedom.
This wouldn't end political conflict. People can be intolerant without a sacred text. It would remove one way of presenting a human preference as a command from an authority no citizen can question or vote out.
We don't have a laboratory in which to compare the same country with and without religion. We do have societies where traditional religious belief and participation are relatively low.
Sociologist Phil Zuckerman examined research on secular populations in a 2009 article in Sociology Compass. His review reported that atheism and secularity were, in various studies, 'positively correlated with societal well-being.'[5] That is a finding about association, not proof that disbelief caused the good outcomes.
The 2026 World Happiness Report offers another useful comparison. Finland ranked first in average life evaluations, Iceland second, and Denmark third. Sweden came fifth and Norway sixth. But Costa Rica, a country with a comparatively stronger religious culture, came fourth.[6]
These rankings aren't scores for atheism. Economic conditions, public institutions, social trust, health, and other factors shape how people evaluate their lives. Nordic countries also retain religious histories and communities, even where conventional belief has declined.
Still, the comparison undermines a sweeping claim: that societies with little religious devotion must collapse into misery or immorality. Clearly, widespread worship is not a prerequisite for high reported life satisfaction.
That doesn't tell us what would happen if every religious institution vanished. It tells us that people are capable of organizing successful lives and public institutions without making religious devotion the center of society.
Here's where the thought experiment gets more difficult. Imagine a small town whose church runs the food pantry, visits elderly residents, arranges childcare, and provides a place for neighbors to see each other every week. If belief disappeared tomorrow, those needs wouldn't disappear with it.
Religious communities often do valuable work. Psychologists Ara Norenzayan and Azim Shariff described religious prosociality as the hypothesis that religions 'facilitate costly behaviors that benefit other people.'[7] Their 2008 review also examined the circumstances and limits of the evidence, rather than claiming that religion always makes people generous.
Pew Research Center's 2019 international analysis found that people who actively participated in religious congregations were often happier and more civically engaged than less-active or unaffiliated adults. In the United States, 36 percent of actively religious adults called themselves very happy, compared with 25 percent of inactive and unaffiliated adults.[8]
That result deserves to be taken seriously. But the same report warned that participation and well-being are linked in ways that are difficult to untangle. Congregations provide friendships, routines, support, and opportunities to volunteer. People who are already socially active may also be more likely to join them.[8]
So what replaces the church? A secular society would need neighborhood organizations, community centers, volunteer networks, mutual-aid groups, and ceremonies that people actually want to attend. Those things need buildings, money, leadership, and time. They don't spring into existence when someone stops believing in God.
A former church could become a library or a shelter. Donations once made to congregations could support hospitals or food programs. But they wouldn't necessarily do so. Some people give precisely because of their religious identity or attachment to a community. Any proposal to redirect religious resources must account for the services those resources already fund.
And not everything religion leaves behind needs to be demolished. Cathedrals, music, literature, festivals, and family traditions can retain cultural value even when their supernatural claims are no longer accepted. We can admire a temple without believing its gods exist.
The goal wouldn't be to replace worship with nothing. It would be to preserve the human benefits of belonging while removing the expectation that belonging requires a creed.
What is a life worth if it ends?
A world without religion would also have to confront an unsettling possibility: we may never see the people we love again after they die. There may be no cosmic judgment to correct the injustices that go unpunished in this life.
Religion offers many people real comfort on those questions. Losing that comfort can hurt. But whether a belief is comforting and whether it is true are different questions.
In his 1925 essay What I Believe, Bertrand Russell described the kind of life he wanted to defend:
Russell didn't need a promise of eternity to give love and knowledge value. Neither do the parents raising a child, the nurse caring for a patient, or the friend sitting beside someone in grief.
Philosopher Erik Wielenberg examined meaning under the assumptions that God, immortal souls, and an afterlife do not exist. His 2022 chapter identified love, meaningful activity, worthwhile commitments, and contributions to others as possible sources of meaning. He concluded that the claim that atheism entails meaninglessness is implausible.[10]
That doesn't prove everyone will feel fulfilled without faith. Some people would miss the assurance that their suffering fits into a divine plan. But a finite life needn't be a pointless one. A song isn't worthless because it ends. Neither is a relationship.
We might become more protective of the little time we know we have. Or some of us might struggle more with loss. A truthful picture of a nonreligious future has to allow for both.
Religion has sometimes helped justify persecution, exclusion, and violence. It has also motivated reconciliation, resistance to injustice, and humanitarian work. Wars and social divisions rarely have a single cause; religious identities can mix with struggles over territory, power, resources, and ethnicity.
Removing religion would remove some theological reasons for treating outsiders as enemies. It would not remove the human habit of dividing the world into insiders and outsiders. Nationalism, political extremism, and conspiracy movements can become rigid and punitive without invoking a god.
That is also why a world that freely moved beyond religion should not be confused with a state that banned it. Government-enforced atheism would replace voluntary inquiry with coercion. A free secular society must protect freedom of conscience, including the right to believe things that most neighbors reject.
The hardest test of a postreligious society wouldn't be whether its citizens could criticize the Bible or the Quran. It would be whether they could challenge their own preferred leaders, moral assumptions, and political movements with the same intellectual honesty.
The world we'd have to build
Picture an ordinary day in that possible future. A child studies evolution without being told that scientific evidence threatens her worth. Two people marry without needing religious approval. Volunteers serve dinner at a community center because hungry neighbors need food, not because an invisible authority ordered them to help.
A family gathers for a funeral. There is no promise of reunion in heaven, but there are photographs, familiar stories, laughter, and grief. The life they're remembering mattered to the people who shared it.
None of those scenes requires religion. But neither do they happen automatically in its absence. Someone has to teach the child, protect the couple's rights, organize the volunteers, and make room for the grieving family.
I don't think religion is responsible for everything wrong with civilization, and I don't think atheism is a shortcut to virtue. People will still be selfish, frightened, tribal, and occasionally cruel. They will also still be generous, curious, creative, and capable of change.
What a world without religion could offer is the chance to organize those human capacities without treating any claimed revelation as the final word. We could judge laws by their effects on people, knowledge by evidence, and communities by how well they care for their members.
If we want justice, we would have to build institutions that deliver it. If we want children to think freely, we would have to teach them how. If we want people to belong, we would have to make places for them. No divine intervention could be counted on to finish the work.
Maybe a world without religion would be better. Maybe it would reveal problems we once blamed on religion but never learned to solve. Either way, its success would depend less on what humanity stopped believing than on what humanity chose to do.
But how much of that actually requires religion? We can love our families without believing in God. We can build hospitals, oppose injustice, and investigate the universe without appealing to scripture. And we can find purpose in a life that may be the only one we have.
Imagine a world where people gradually stopped believing in gods, not because a government forbade religion, but because supernatural explanations no longer persuaded them. Would it be a kinder, freer, more knowledgeable world? Or would we discover that religious institutions had been providing things we weren't prepared to replace?
A completely nonreligious world has never existed, so we can't know its future. But philosophy, social science, and the experience of relatively secular societies give us something better than a guess: evidence about which parts of human life depend on religion, and which do not.
Who decides what is right without God?
One common objection to atheism is that without divine commandments, morality becomes a matter of personal preference. If no one is watching from heaven, why shouldn't someone lie, steal, or hurt others whenever doing so is convenient?
That question assumes religion solves the problem of moral justification. Yet philosophers were questioning the relationship between goodness and divine approval more than two thousand years ago. In Plato's Euthyphro, Socrates asks:
Is that which is holy loved by the gods because it is holy, or is it holy because it is loved by the gods?[1]
Put simply, is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is already good? The first answer raises the worry that morality depends on whatever God happens to command. The second leaves us asking what makes an action good apart from the command.
Christian philosophers have offered serious responses, including the view that goodness reflects God's nature rather than arbitrary decisions. That may answer the charge of arbitrariness within their theology, but it does not establish that we must believe in God to recognize cruelty or reason about justice.
John Stuart Mill offered one influential nonreligious approach in his 1863 essay Utilitarianism:
Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.[2]
Mill's proposal can be criticized, particularly when the interests of a majority threaten the rights of a minority. But it puts a public question on the table: who is helped or harmed by an action, and why should we accept that harm? Other secular approaches emphasize duties, rights, fairness, or character. They disagree, just as religious moral systems do.
Our moral instincts also have a social history. Cooperation, empathy, and concern for reputation can be studied as features of human behavior, even if those facts alone cannot tell us what we ought to do. Explaining how morality develops is not the same as proving a moral rule.
The claim that belief in God is necessary for morality is already losing public support. In Pew Research Center's 2025 survey, published in March 2026, 68 percent of American adults said belief in God was not necessary to be moral and have good values. In Sweden, 89 percent said the same.[3]
A world without religion wouldn't stop us arguing about justice. It would require us to defend moral rules without expecting the words 'God says so' to end the discussion.
What changes when scripture no longer sets the limits?
Consider a classroom where students are learning how life evolved. Some religious people accept evolution, and many scientists have been believers. The conflict arises when a religious account is presented as a competing scientific explanation without meeting scientific standards.
In Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science, the National Academy of Sciences explained that science tests explanations against evidence and that creation science does not satisfy those methods. It argued that evolution, rather than a religious account of creation, belongs in the science curriculum.[4]
A society doesn't need to abandon religious belief to teach science properly. It needs to reject the idea that a doctrine deserves scientific status simply because people consider it sacred. In a world without religion, that particular conflict would largely disappear.
The same principle extends to law. Religious citizens should be free to practice their beliefs, argue for their values, and participate in politics. But a law that restricts someone else's freedom should have reasons that citizens outside that religion can examine.
A marriage law, a medical policy, or a school curriculum should be defensible in terms of rights, evidence, and consequences. Saying that God disapproves might explain a believer's conviction, but it doesn't give everyone else a reason to surrender their freedom.
This wouldn't end political conflict. People can be intolerant without a sacred text. It would remove one way of presenting a human preference as a command from an authority no citizen can question or vote out.
The societies already living with less religion
We don't have a laboratory in which to compare the same country with and without religion. We do have societies where traditional religious belief and participation are relatively low.
Sociologist Phil Zuckerman examined research on secular populations in a 2009 article in Sociology Compass. His review reported that atheism and secularity were, in various studies, 'positively correlated with societal well-being.'[5] That is a finding about association, not proof that disbelief caused the good outcomes.
The 2026 World Happiness Report offers another useful comparison. Finland ranked first in average life evaluations, Iceland second, and Denmark third. Sweden came fifth and Norway sixth. But Costa Rica, a country with a comparatively stronger religious culture, came fourth.[6]
These rankings aren't scores for atheism. Economic conditions, public institutions, social trust, health, and other factors shape how people evaluate their lives. Nordic countries also retain religious histories and communities, even where conventional belief has declined.
Still, the comparison undermines a sweeping claim: that societies with little religious devotion must collapse into misery or immorality. Clearly, widespread worship is not a prerequisite for high reported life satisfaction.
That doesn't tell us what would happen if every religious institution vanished. It tells us that people are capable of organizing successful lives and public institutions without making religious devotion the center of society.
Who would take care of the people churches now help?
Here's where the thought experiment gets more difficult. Imagine a small town whose church runs the food pantry, visits elderly residents, arranges childcare, and provides a place for neighbors to see each other every week. If belief disappeared tomorrow, those needs wouldn't disappear with it.
Religious communities often do valuable work. Psychologists Ara Norenzayan and Azim Shariff described religious prosociality as the hypothesis that religions 'facilitate costly behaviors that benefit other people.'[7] Their 2008 review also examined the circumstances and limits of the evidence, rather than claiming that religion always makes people generous.
Pew Research Center's 2019 international analysis found that people who actively participated in religious congregations were often happier and more civically engaged than less-active or unaffiliated adults. In the United States, 36 percent of actively religious adults called themselves very happy, compared with 25 percent of inactive and unaffiliated adults.[8]
That result deserves to be taken seriously. But the same report warned that participation and well-being are linked in ways that are difficult to untangle. Congregations provide friendships, routines, support, and opportunities to volunteer. People who are already socially active may also be more likely to join them.[8]
So what replaces the church? A secular society would need neighborhood organizations, community centers, volunteer networks, mutual-aid groups, and ceremonies that people actually want to attend. Those things need buildings, money, leadership, and time. They don't spring into existence when someone stops believing in God.
A former church could become a library or a shelter. Donations once made to congregations could support hospitals or food programs. But they wouldn't necessarily do so. Some people give precisely because of their religious identity or attachment to a community. Any proposal to redirect religious resources must account for the services those resources already fund.
And not everything religion leaves behind needs to be demolished. Cathedrals, music, literature, festivals, and family traditions can retain cultural value even when their supernatural claims are no longer accepted. We can admire a temple without believing its gods exist.
The goal wouldn't be to replace worship with nothing. It would be to preserve the human benefits of belonging while removing the expectation that belonging requires a creed.
What is a life worth if it ends?
A world without religion would also have to confront an unsettling possibility: we may never see the people we love again after they die. There may be no cosmic judgment to correct the injustices that go unpunished in this life.
Religion offers many people real comfort on those questions. Losing that comfort can hurt. But whether a belief is comforting and whether it is true are different questions.
In his 1925 essay What I Believe, Bertrand Russell described the kind of life he wanted to defend:
The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge.[9]
Russell didn't need a promise of eternity to give love and knowledge value. Neither do the parents raising a child, the nurse caring for a patient, or the friend sitting beside someone in grief.
Philosopher Erik Wielenberg examined meaning under the assumptions that God, immortal souls, and an afterlife do not exist. His 2022 chapter identified love, meaningful activity, worthwhile commitments, and contributions to others as possible sources of meaning. He concluded that the claim that atheism entails meaninglessness is implausible.[10]
That doesn't prove everyone will feel fulfilled without faith. Some people would miss the assurance that their suffering fits into a divine plan. But a finite life needn't be a pointless one. A song isn't worthless because it ends. Neither is a relationship.
We might become more protective of the little time we know we have. Or some of us might struggle more with loss. A truthful picture of a nonreligious future has to allow for both.
Would the world be more peaceful?
Religion has sometimes helped justify persecution, exclusion, and violence. It has also motivated reconciliation, resistance to injustice, and humanitarian work. Wars and social divisions rarely have a single cause; religious identities can mix with struggles over territory, power, resources, and ethnicity.
Removing religion would remove some theological reasons for treating outsiders as enemies. It would not remove the human habit of dividing the world into insiders and outsiders. Nationalism, political extremism, and conspiracy movements can become rigid and punitive without invoking a god.
That is also why a world that freely moved beyond religion should not be confused with a state that banned it. Government-enforced atheism would replace voluntary inquiry with coercion. A free secular society must protect freedom of conscience, including the right to believe things that most neighbors reject.
The hardest test of a postreligious society wouldn't be whether its citizens could criticize the Bible or the Quran. It would be whether they could challenge their own preferred leaders, moral assumptions, and political movements with the same intellectual honesty.
The world we'd have to build
Picture an ordinary day in that possible future. A child studies evolution without being told that scientific evidence threatens her worth. Two people marry without needing religious approval. Volunteers serve dinner at a community center because hungry neighbors need food, not because an invisible authority ordered them to help.
A family gathers for a funeral. There is no promise of reunion in heaven, but there are photographs, familiar stories, laughter, and grief. The life they're remembering mattered to the people who shared it.
None of those scenes requires religion. But neither do they happen automatically in its absence. Someone has to teach the child, protect the couple's rights, organize the volunteers, and make room for the grieving family.
I don't think religion is responsible for everything wrong with civilization, and I don't think atheism is a shortcut to virtue. People will still be selfish, frightened, tribal, and occasionally cruel. They will also still be generous, curious, creative, and capable of change.
What a world without religion could offer is the chance to organize those human capacities without treating any claimed revelation as the final word. We could judge laws by their effects on people, knowledge by evidence, and communities by how well they care for their members.
If we want justice, we would have to build institutions that deliver it. If we want children to think freely, we would have to teach them how. If we want people to belong, we would have to make places for them. No divine intervention could be counted on to finish the work.
Maybe a world without religion would be better. Maybe it would reveal problems we once blamed on religion but never learned to solve. Either way, its success would depend less on what humanity stopped believing than on what humanity chose to do.
_____
Sources
[1] Plato. Euthyphro, 10a, trans. Benjamin Jowett. The Internet Classics Archive. View source.
[2] Mill, John Stuart. Utilitarianism (1863), chap. 2, 'What Utilitarianism Is.' Project Gutenberg. View source.
[3] Pew Research Center. 'In the U.S. and Other Countries, Fewer People Now Say It's Necessary to Believe in God to Be Moral.' March 5, 2026. View source.
[4] National Academy of Sciences. Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 1998, 'Religious Issues' and 'Educational Issues.' View source.
[5] Zuckerman, Phil. 'Atheism, Secularity, and Well-Being: How the Findings of Social Science Counter Negative Stereotypes and Assumptions.' Sociology Compass 3, no. 6 (2009): 949–971. View source.
[6] Ray, Julie. 'Happiness Rankings Show Stability and Change.' Gallup, March 18, 2026, reporting the World Happiness Report 2026 country rankings. View source.
[7] Norenzayan, Ara, and Azim F. Shariff. 'The Origin and Evolution of Religious Prosociality.' Science 322, no. 5898 (2008): 58–62. View source.
[8] Pew Research Center. 'Religion's Relationship to Happiness, Civic Engagement and Health Around the World.' January 31, 2019. View source.
[9] Russell, Bertrand. What I Believe (1925), chap. 2, 'The Good Life.' Wikisource edition. View source.
[10] Wielenberg, Erik J. 'Atheism and Meaning in Life.' In The Oxford Handbook of Meaning in Life, 216–228. Oxford University Press, 2022. View source.
Sources
[1] Plato. Euthyphro, 10a, trans. Benjamin Jowett. The Internet Classics Archive. View source.
[2] Mill, John Stuart. Utilitarianism (1863), chap. 2, 'What Utilitarianism Is.' Project Gutenberg. View source.
[3] Pew Research Center. 'In the U.S. and Other Countries, Fewer People Now Say It's Necessary to Believe in God to Be Moral.' March 5, 2026. View source.
[4] National Academy of Sciences. Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 1998, 'Religious Issues' and 'Educational Issues.' View source.
[5] Zuckerman, Phil. 'Atheism, Secularity, and Well-Being: How the Findings of Social Science Counter Negative Stereotypes and Assumptions.' Sociology Compass 3, no. 6 (2009): 949–971. View source.
[6] Ray, Julie. 'Happiness Rankings Show Stability and Change.' Gallup, March 18, 2026, reporting the World Happiness Report 2026 country rankings. View source.
[7] Norenzayan, Ara, and Azim F. Shariff. 'The Origin and Evolution of Religious Prosociality.' Science 322, no. 5898 (2008): 58–62. View source.
[8] Pew Research Center. 'Religion's Relationship to Happiness, Civic Engagement and Health Around the World.' January 31, 2019. View source.
[9] Russell, Bertrand. What I Believe (1925), chap. 2, 'The Good Life.' Wikisource edition. View source.
[10] Wielenberg, Erik J. 'Atheism and Meaning in Life.' In The Oxford Handbook of Meaning in Life, 216–228. Oxford University Press, 2022. View source.
Comments
Post a Comment