Skip to main content
Some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links. We may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.

The Peacemaker Summit, Part 2: Keynotes to the Kingdom

Image
By

Click here for part 1!

Following some initial audio/visual difficulties (which drove my professional A/V friend crazy), the Peacemaker Summit finally got underway with some introductory remarks by Marla Gale, the event sponsor, then by Travish Lish and Christian Williams, the co-owners of The Holy Rebellion social media accounts. What followed over the next several hours were eight keynote addresses and a lunch break.

Alternatively, skip to the end to see my final thoughts.

In summarizing and evaluating each speaker, I'm employing the rubric below (I am a teacher, after all):

Does the speaker...

  1. have a consistent thesis related to the stated mission of the conference?
  2. clearly articulate an application of content creation online?
  3. rigorously demonstrate an actionable metric for peacemaking?
  4. utilize a high-quality and engaging presentational format?

Christian Williams: "The Accusatory Fog & Two Ineffective Responses" @theholyrebellion

Christian begins his address the same way he does his interview with Greg Matsen - that he and Travis pivoted away from interfaith dialogue in order to "shepherd the flocks of the king" through LDS apologetics and devotional content creation. Christian alleges that the appropriate space for "critical content" regarding the LDS faith is through the #exmormon hashtag, which Christian claims has overtaken the internet only because faithful LDS members have "abdicated" the online "battlefield."

This leads to Christian's call to action: comment, like, and follow The Holy Rebellion - or, I'm sorry, "faithful content" - turning the algorithm into a tool for LDS "member missionaries," a popular title in LDS communities. "There's some sedentary guy in his basement 500 miles away calling you names," Christian reassures the audience, meaning there's no need to fear responding to them, turning the social media "warzone" into a "vineyard."

This seems lackluster even for an introductory speech. Christian's advice seems more of a plug for his own channel; he praises the desire for creating content creation but gives no mission statements or objectives in general; his solution for creating peacemaking content is to classify the opposition as basement-dwellers, and he frequently pauses to invoke the soft "missionary voice" as a replacement for informative supporting details (he doesn't even fulfill the title he apparently went with).

Thesis: D
Application: D
Metric: F
Format: F
Christian's Grade: D-

Cade Alvey: "Theology Sucks!" @allthoseinfavor


Cade presents this title as the "thesis" for his address, drawing on a story of one Caspar Zacher, a 16th-century German who was found not guilty of heresy because he was, in fact, a rather coarse and belligerent man rather than the pacifistic and compassionate (but heretical) Anabaptists who he had been accused of associating with. With this anecdote, Cade declares all "orthodoxy" to be "boiled down to a list of propositions" presented as a quiz of Christian identity politics, which in Cade's view entirely misses the "shared life in Christ" that Cade believes the Christian gospel is meant to produce. Discussions over theology must be abdicated within LDS engagement, Cade warns, if they are to pursue a Christlike spirit.

Cade's talk abruptly concludes with several nebulous couplets: that Christians should heal the world rather than fight it, replace posturing with embracing (I think, at least; Cade merely pantomimes a bear hug and juxtaposes it with a boxing stance), and find purpose in "shining light into dark places." Cade never elaborates on any of these metaphors.

Thesis: F
Application: F
Metric: F
Format: D
Cade's Grade: F

Baylor Johnson: "The Peacemaker's Guide to War" @allthoseinfavor


Baylor first recounts hearing contradictory advice from two podcasts about the nutritional value of olive oil. Baylor admits he tends to assume a claimant is correct because they are making the claim in the first place (which reminded me of this viral clip). Baylor asserts that this is where LDS members and defenders often "win the battle but lose the war" by failing to engage with the claimant at all, making them appear the victor by default. Instead, Baylor contends, LDS members should engage with critical content with their own perspectives, seek to be peacemakers rather than rude or condescending ("the viewer will never side with a jerk"), and to validate the lived experiences of the claimants to break down barriers of identity politics.

Baylor attempts to drive this home with the observation that, while Jesus flipped tables in the temple, "You aren't Jesus! If you think you're Jesus, there's bigger questions to figure out here." Baylor gives the audience the admonition that they will be accountable to anyone who is offended by their words or actions, that peacemaking represents seeking the opposite of those things: to see a broader perspective of the conflict and avoid a pyrrhic victory that tarnishes the reputation of the LDS church and its membership. However noble the allegorical intent, the advice fails to become more than platitudes that can be tergiversated to excuse any number of behaviors online, toxic or not.

Thesis: C
Application: B-
Metric: C-
Format: C
Baylor's Grade: C

Maddy Packer: "From Passive to Peacemaker"
@thesurefoundation


Citing the need for multiple perspectives on peacemaking, Maddy approaches her address as the classic devotional speech featured weekly in LDS sacrament meetings, complete with spliced quotes from a variety of modern LDS leaders and various verses of LDS scripture. Maddy insists that peacemaking is possible without compromising on "difficult conversations" about LDS doctrine and theology, as Maddy sees "peacemaking" often conflated with "peacekeeping," which she goes on to compare and contrast:

Peacekeeping                   Peacemaking
avoids conflict                    disrupts conflict
provides comfort                challenges comfort
seeks not to offend            seeks truth
submits to defeat               defies defeat
easy                                   hard

In Maddy's mind, it's not the avoidance of contention, but the boldness, that separates the peacemaker from the peacekeeper. Peace is achieved when the enemies of God are made to be silent, as Maddy references the strawman stories of "anti-Christs" in the Book of Mormon who the prophets contend with boldly until the opposition is somehow easily and immediately confounded. Maddy even classifies Jesus flipping tables at the temple as a form of "peacemaking" by being brave enough to expose evil, an example that Maddy believes was teaching us to follow in his footsteps to walk the line "between submission and retaliation...cunning as serpents and harmless as doves."

Thesis: B
Application: D-
Metric: C-
Format: D
Maddy's Grade: D+

Jasmin Rappleye: "Answering Hard Questions with Compassion and Boldness" @jasminrappleye


Jasmin states her address is intended to be a "tactical, step-by-step breakdown" of how she approaches content creation, and it shows. Using an infamous image of former LDS president Heber J. Grant at a meeting with a Nazi flag just behind him, Jasmin creates a case study of how to combat the human fight-or-flight impulse and learn to respond constructively to misinformation about LDS doctrine or history.
  1. Identify why the criticism feels uncomfortable or painful
  2. Study "trustworthy" sources and primary documents
  3. Communicate the central thesis as supported by your sources
  4. Draft a script with your content platform and audience in mind
  5. Review and revise based on peer and valued input
  6. Align your content and feedback with your identity and values
With each point, Jasmin engages the audience with concrete examples and applications, effortlessly drawing attention toward herself and her presentation with compelling visuals and clear language. Jasmin highlights how online content can often be used to sensationalize or muddy the waters of discourse; or even worse, be intensely uninteresting and fail to reward the effort put into creating the content. Jasmin gives this comparison: "Immature students see critique as a threat or insult; insecure students see critique as a sign of failure; flourishing students respect and evaluate critical feedback with both humility and confidence." She even shows off her personal mission statement and invites online influencers to adapt it to their own needs and priorities.

My only real complaint with Jasmin's address is the final product of this case study is a short reel that pivots to her YouTube podcast, Informed Saints, rather than the informational communication she promised was on her checklist of objectives. For the price of admission, couldn't the audience get an advance screening of her full response? Still, this is good advice for any content creator, not just the LDS ones.

Thesis: A
Application: A
Metric: B+
Format: A
Jasmin's Grade: A

David Snell: "Balancing Difficult Topics While Growing Testimony" @keystonelds


The final and longest speech of the summit's morning session, David pursues a number of convoluted and clumsy allegories to put forth the concept that there are stages of faith that move from simplicity to complexity to what David calls "simplicity beyond complexity," although David never explains what that means in a gospel or apologetic context. David reminds the audience not to neglect their own needs as they pursue online discourse and that they have a responsibility to love their neighbors, aka "the random people on the internet." From scuba diving to gardening to the Golden Gate Bridge, David repeats the theme of making large achievements through tenacity and patience.

Thesis: D
Application: F
Metric: D
Format: B-
David's Grade: D

Jared Halverson: "Detecting Misinformation Online" @unshakensaints


A current CES instructor (the LDS educational wing), Jared gives the longest keynote speech at the conference. Jared treats us to a meta-historical view of the innovations of communication across human history, and how in each stage there have been those who are concerned that new methods of communication - from written text to the printing press to social media to AI - would somehow dilute human society and its ability to progress or trust each other. Jared insists that this has applicative power within LDS tradition to: contrary to repeated warnings by LDS leaders and even others at the Peacemaker Summit, the rise of online discourse is something that will strengthen the LDS church rather than weaken it.

Jared characterizes misinformation (that is, information on the LDS church that is deemed incorrect or inappropriate) as sensationalized, superficial, and selective. Responses from LDS members ought to fulfill the "opposite" criteria: faithful, from an eternal perspective, using "reliable" sources. Jared also notes that the "blackwashing" of the LDS church from critics is often rooted in the same motivations that drives LDS defenders to "whitewash" the same topics and warns LDS members not to overstate their case anymore than the critic.

Thesis: B+
Application: D+
Metric: B-
Format: C-
Jared's Grade: C+

Concluding Thoughts

I tried to avoid as much editorializing as I could in my summary of each speech, but you may have caught a few of the same observations I did.

Firstly, there was never a clear or consistent definition of what "peacemaking" was. Each speaker seemed to have differing and even contradictory notions of how peace would look in the utopia promised by The Holy Rebellion. My favorite contradiction of this sort was Baylor's reprimand of anyone thinking they could toss tables as Jesus did, while Maddy as the very next speaker said Jesus's flipping tables was an example to us of how to be bold. Meanwhile, Cade seemed adamant that LDS online discourse ought to recuse itself from topics of theology, whereas Christian earlier had decried that as abdication from the divine mandate of the gospel of Jesus Christ. 

Secondly, it was clear from the keynote speakers why most conferences of this type take far more planning and preparation than The Holy Rebellion was willing to give for whatever reason they thought they had. Speaker presentations were clearly not coordinated or correlated with even a common mission statement, as if their mere identity as card-carrying Mormons was enough to establish a coherent mission statement, which outside of Jasmin was never communicated by anyone.

Lastly, these were long speeches that were mostly about platitudes and flowery metaphors rather than anything that an aspiring content creator could use to their advantage. I cut out a lot of fluff from almost every address, or was able to sum up their longwinded allegories in a sentence or two. The Holy Rebellion would go on at the end of the conference to advertise a separate event that would actually go into the technical details of content creation, which calls into question what the purpose even was for this conference!

After Halverson we have the AMA panels, which ended up being a microcosm of the same complaints I had about the keynote speakers, and which I'll be covering in part 3. Until then, adieu. 
Category:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mormon Blood and the Esther Cohen-Tizer-Epstein Letter

By Mason
With the recent release of nearly 3.5 million pages of the Epstein files, there have been several connections made regarding Jeffery Epstein paying tuition for several students at BYU. The most notable of which is presented in what is known as the Esther Cohen-Tizer-Epstien Letter.    Some are questioning the authenticity of the letter, but some clues seem to point us to a woman named   Esther Cohen .  Lets look at a few connections. Note that these connections are not an attempt at making any accusations and are simply connections made through publicly available information. I will be updating this page as I find more information. EFTA00129111  Reference to the Seven Bowls School of Nutrition From Esther's website: alchemyofnourishment.com She began studying nutrition as a teenager: Which also seems to align with her site. Alchemy of Nourishment Along with the claim of residing in Colorado Alchemy of Nourishment The final piece of the puzzle is a 2017 revi...
2 comments
Read

The Peacemaker Summit and an Attempt to Silence Mormonism's Critics

By Mason
 An upcoming event called the Peacemaker Summit , organized by The Holy Rebellion , is being promoted as a gathering for faithful LDS creators. The organizing vision for this event is explicitly about displacing critics of the faith by flooding social media platforms with coordinated, high-volume pro-Mormon content. That goal deserves scrutiny. My initial reaction to the original video The Stated Aim: Outnumber the Critics Travis Lish and Christian Williams from The Holy Rebellion have been clear about their motivation. They believe critics of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints dominate online spaces and that faithful voices need to overwhelm that presence. The solution being proposed is to create enough volume to hide criticisms from search results.  ... our goal is 1 billion views per month  collectively  as Latter Day Saint creators. Imagine a world where when you search Mormon or LDS or Joseph Smith  across any platform, what you would see...
1 comment
Read

The "Mormon" Trademark is About to Expire

By Mason
 The request for Mormon Stories to rebrand has spread quickly through Mormon spaces. Followers learned that om November 14th 2025, the LDS Church had reached out with claims that the podcast was infringing on the “Mormon” trademark. The demand leaned on the legal idea that the Church owns the word.  The request was shared on social media by @mormstories, but those posts seem to have been removed. Fortunately, copies of the email were  shared on reddit. But there is a significant detail sitting behind this entire dispute. The Church will have to renew the "Mormon" trademark in the 2026 to 2027 window.  Source: USPTO database When that time comes, they must prove that they still use the word “Mormon” in active commerce. USPTO rules are clear on this point. A trademark only survives if the owner can show that it is still printed on actual goods or services that are still being sold or distributed. The official guidelines spell it out at uspto.gov under “ Keeping your r...
3 comments
Read

Where Did Joseph Smith Dig for Treasure?

By Mason
Before Joseph Smith was known as a prophet, he was known locally for treasure digging. An article written by Dan Vogel   mapped out the physical locations connected to that earlier phase of Smith’s life. Drawing from court records, affidavits, neighbor testimony, and later reminiscences, Vogel was able to place Smith on specific hillsides, farms, and riverbanks across western New York and northern Pennsylvania. Show Dan Vogel's Full Article (If you have issues on mobile, you can read the full document  here ) The article itself is a valuable asset to anybody who wants to understand the treasure digging activities of Joseph Smith. However, due to the design of the maps provided it may be difficult to immediate tell where the digs took place. Which in my opinion, may limit the sharing of his research. As such, I took it upon myself to update the map in Google Earth using Dan Vogel's research as my guide. This gives us a bit of clearer idea of w...
Post a Comment
Read

Encouraging Marriage: Lowering the Age for Female Missionaries

By Mason
 In October 2012, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints officially lowered the minimum age for missionary service. Before that change, men could begin at age 19 and women at age 21. The update allowed men to start at 18 and women at 19, a major shift in how young Latter-day Saints approached their early adult years. That change dramatically increased missionary numbers, with applications skyrocketing in the weeks after the announcement and women making up a much larger share of those who served.   For more than a decade after that update, the rule stayed the same. Women could serve at 19 and men at 18, with women serving 18-month missions and men serving two years. In November 2025 the Church again changed the rule: the minimum age for women to serve was lowered to 18, equalizing it with men.  What made this new policy notable wasn’t just equality in age; it was the statements that came with it.   In a January 2026 interview with the Church’s own Deseret News, Presid...
Post a Comment
Read

Early Mormon Criticisms - 4: Fanaticism

By Mason
 This series looks back at how early critics of the church reacted to the rise of Mormonism. Some mocked it, others warned against it, and a few tried to make sense of it. Each post features a historical excerpt and some brief context to show how critics viewed the new faith as it was unfolding.  -The full series can be found  here - The article titled “Fanaticism” was published on February 11, 1831, in the United States Gazette , a Philadelphia paper with national circulation. It reprints material from the Painesville Gazette , reflecting local reports from northeastern Ohio rather than direct investigation by the Gazette itself. The author is unnamed, consistent with early-19th-century newspaper practice, and the tone reflects mainstream Protestant skepticism toward emerging religious movements. The piece focuses on Kirtland and nearby areas in Geauga and Cuyahoga counties at a very early stage in Mormon development, less than a year after the Book of Mormon’s publica...
Post a Comment
Read

The LDS Church Flip-Flopped on the KJV

By
Recently , the LDS church announced updated guidance on the "approved" list of Bible translation for use in local congregations, spanning both English and international language versions. You can find the specifics of this guidance in the LDS General Handbook . The Updated Narrative On January 6, 2026, an interview was hosted by BYU to highlight the updated LDS Bible recommendations: Josh Sears, Associate Professor of Ancient Scripture [L]anguage just keeps evolving. That's a natural thing. And that's nothing to be afraid of. That's just how language works. And we see out throughout history that as language gets of the scriptures gets too far removed from what people are speaking, there's always a need to update and modernize ... So, when the announcement came about the handbook updates that were going to be more flexible and allow for a variety of translations to work alongside the King James, it didn't really surprise me because to me this was aligned ...
Post a Comment
Read

LDS Apologists Try to Beat a Dead Horse

By
It looks like the topic of horses and the Book of Mormon is going to crop up every few months like a nasty case of eczema, so I feel it’s worthwhile to summarize the debate as it currently stands. There's another post on this blog  about more recent research, but it always goes back to the (in)famous analysis done by Matthew Roper and his colleagues at BYU, John Clark and Wade Ardern, all the way back to 2005. But first, let's look even further back.  What the Book of Mormon Said The word “horse” appears 14 total times in the Book of Mormon in the context of domesticated livestock, with half of those references being connected with pulling chariots of war. Both Lamanite and Nephite peoples equated these horses with those described in Isaiah 2:7 and 5:28, which Nephi expressly quotes in his own record (compare 2 Nephi 12:7 and 15:28), with no distinction made between them. The horses of the Americas, per the Book of Mormon, are intended to be the same in form and function to ...
Post a Comment
Read

Full Text - Mormons Taking Oaths of the Temple House (1904)

By Mason
  This article appeared in 1904, during the height of national scrutiny surrounding the LDS Church and the U.S. Senate investigation into whether Apostle Reed Smoot should be seated as a senator. At the center of that inquiry were questions the public had debated for decades but rarely heard addressed in sworn testimony.  What actually happened inside the Endowment House ?  What oaths were required?  Do the oaths conflict with civic loyalty, democratic norms, and basic transparency? The reporting below relies on testimony given under oath to the Senate Committee on Privileges and Elections and presents the claims exactly as they were reported to a national audience. This was not written as theology or internal instruction. It was written as political journalism, aimed at informing a non-Mormon public that largely had no access to temple ceremonies and relied on secondhand descriptions. THE WASHINGTON TIMES DECEMBER 14, 1904 MORMONS TAKING OATHS OF ENDOWMENT HOUS...
Post a Comment
Read

There Is No Curse, Part 5: Then What Is It?

By
We need to talk about the current apologetics attempting to downplay the Lamanite curse. Nephi Sees Our Day In preparation for my next topic, I was reading 1 Nephi 13:15 , where Nephi sees a vision of the future for his own civilization and the European conquest of America. This passage stuck out to me: And I beheld the Spirit of the Lord, that it was upon the Gentiles, and they did prosper and obtain the land for their inheritance; and I beheld that they were white, and exceedingly fair and beautiful, like unto my people before they were slain. This is in direct contrast to 1 Nephi 12:23 : And it came to pass that I beheld, after they had dwindled in unbelief they became a dark, and loathsome, and a filthy people, full of idleness and all manner of abominations. You might notice that there is ample ambiguity in both passages, but in juxtaposing these two peoples, we see a contrast that I just can’t reconcile if the curse is only “symbolic” or “spiritual.” In comparing Gentiles to Lam...
Post a Comment
Read
e
Link copied!